How to do evidence based hiring?

4 mins
Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    A few years back, a friend of mine was struggling with hiring the right employees. He was tired of the traditional hiring methods that relied on gut feelings and intuition and wanted to find a better way to identify the best candidates. One day, he came across a concept called “Evidence-Based Hiring.” He learned that it was a data-driven approach to hiring that relied on objective, verifiable evidence to assess candidates. He gathered data on his top-performing employees` key traits and skills. He used this information to create a set of standardized evidence-based interview questions and assessment tools. Evidence-Based Hiring was the solution needed to improve its hiring process and find top-performing employees who would thrive in their roles.

    What is evidence-based hiring?

    Evidence-based hiring is a systematic and data-driven approach to recruiting and selection. However, Evidence-based hiring involves collecting and analyzing data about candidates and using that data to make informed decisions about who to hire. Evidence-based hiring was founded on the principles of evidence-based decision-making based on scientific research, data analysis, and expert opinion. It is designed to reduce the impact of unconscious biases and increase hiring decisions’ accuracy. However, Recorded Discussions are also a type of evidence that gives interviewers the ability to audit an interview.

    The benefits of evidence-based hiring over traditional hiring practices

    Evidence-based recruitment requires measuring consistent data points over time that show correlations between factors that exist during employment and across an employee’s career. The benefits are many, but what are they?

    1. Employee vacancies can be filled faster

    One of the most tangible benefits of evidence-based recruitment is the wealth of data points that can use to make hiring decisions. Moreover, traditional employment checks a list of skills, work experience, accomplishments, and other personal details. 

    2. You save money in the hiring process

    In business, time is money. Many job boards require payment to post job ads, which costs money. Also, spending days understaffed costs the company money in the form of productivity and other outcomes. 

    3. Reduce turnover and increase overall employee satisfaction

    The main motivators of evidence-based attitudes are long-term job performance and satisfaction.  However, it could be a better result for employees to only stay a few years before leaving the company. 

    4. Improve productivity, and customer satisfaction

    Employees who feel safe and happy at work are more productive individually and as a team. Moreover, our evidence-based attitude helps you build high-performing teams, increase productivity, and easily navigate changing business environments.

    How can interviews be evidence-based?

    Recorded interviews can be evidence-based by incorporating structured and data-driven approaches into the interview process. This means relying on objective data, research, and job analysis to inform the development of interview questions and assessment methods.

    The role of structured interviews in evidence-based hiring

    Although it requires some development up front, choosing the right employees is critical to the success of both corporate and non-profit organizations. However Evidence-based interview questions are questions informed by objective data and research designed to assess the skills and traits most predictive of job success.

    Here are some evidence-based interview questions:

    1. Can you describe a specific accomplishment you are proud of and why?
    2. Can you tell us about a time when you had to deal with a difficult situation at work and how you handled it?
    3. How do you approach problem-solving, and can you give us an example of a problem you solved?
    4. Can you describe a time when you had to work with a team to achieve a common goal?
    5. How do you handle ambiguity and change in the workplace?

    Moreover, these are just a few examples of evidence-based interview questions that organizations can use to assess the skills and traits most predictive of job success. 

    Essential elements for evidence-based interviews

    Evidence-based hiring is a scientific approach to the recruitment and selection process that uses data and research to make informed decisions about a candidate’s suitability for a role. The essential elements for evidence-based interviews include consistency in the interview process, evidence-based job analysis, behavioral interview questions, and gathering data on the candidate’s performance in previous roles.

    1. Consistency in the interview process

    It involves standardizing how interviews are conducted, including the types of questions asked and the criteria used to evaluate candidates. However, this ensures that all candidates are evaluated fairly and eliminates any bias that might arise from inconsistent evidence-based interviewing practices.

    2. Evidence-based job analysis

    Evidence-based job analysis involves identifying the specific skills, knowledge, and abilities required for a role and using that information to create behavioral interview questions. Moreover, behavioral interview questions are designed to elicit specific examples of how a candidate has demonstrated the required skills, knowledge, and abilities in previous roles.

    3. Use of behavioral interview questions

    These questions ask the candidate to describe specific situations from their past, how they handled them, and what the outcome was. however, the focus is on the candidate’s past behavior, which is a good predictor of future behavior. 

    4. Gathering of data on candidate performance in previous roles

    Another key element of evidence-based hiring is gathering data on candidate performance in previous roles. This can include references, performance evaluations, and other sources of information about a candidate’s past performance. 

    BarRaiser Interview Intelligence is a tool that can help organizations implement evidence-based hiring. It provides a platform for creating and conducting structured interviews, and gathering and analyzing data on candidate performance. Moreover also managing the recruitment process. However, by using BarRaiser, organizations can increase the consistency and accuracy of their hiring decisions and make the process more efficient and effective.


    By relying on evidence and data, organizations can reduce the risk of making poor hiring decisions and ensure they make the best choices for their business. With its advanced analytics capabilities, BarRaiser’s Interview Intelligence helps organizations identify skills and traits. however, that are most predictive of job success, enabling them to make more informed decisions about who to hire. However, evidence-based hiring is an effective way to ensure that organizations make the best hiring decisions. Moreover, tools like BarRaiser can be incredibly helpful in achieving this goal.

    Reference links: 

    People also ask

    What are the benefits of evidence-based hiring?

    The benefits of evidence-based hiring include improved accuracy in the selection. Moreover also consistency in the interview process, improved efficiency in the hiring process, better candidate experience, and better performance outcomes.

    What are structured interviews?

    Structured interviews are where the same set of questions are asked to every candidate in the same order and with the same follow-up questions. However, this helps to ensure that the interview process is consistent, fair, and free from bias.

    banner for blogs page

    Experience smarter interviewing with us

    Get the top 1% talent with BarRaiser’s Smart AI Platform